Tech Friday: Oil Cooled Vs Liquid Cooled Engines

Harley Iron 883 Simple Air-Cooled Engine
This Harley Iron 883 Has A Simple Air-Cooled Engine

There’s a new misunderstanding created by the marketing departments of motorcycle manufacturers. It’s called ‘Oil Cooled’ engines. An engine is nothing but a giant block of metal in which countless explosions start happening the moment you turn it on. So, cooling the engine is a critical job as it prevents permanent damage to the internal components.

Liquid-cooled engines are cooled using a liquid. Duh! Oil happens to be a liquid. Then oil cooled equals liquid-cooled. Right?

Wrong. Oil cooled is a nifty feature for motorcycles, but calling it that is surely misleading.

What Is Oil Cooled?

An oil cooled engine has its engine oil circulating through the cooling fins, which in turn are cooled via the flow of air as you ride into the wind.

Royal Enfield himalayan oil cooled engine
Royal Enfield Himalayan Oil Cooled Engine

Also Read: “Much Improved” Royal Enfield Himalayan Coming Soon

If you didn’t know, the engine oil does more than just clean the metallic dirt and lubricate the parts inside the engine block. The heat from the clutch pack also routes through the motor oil, which helps cool down the clutch by spreading it over a larger surface area.

Oil cooling is especially useful if the bike has to see a lot of half-clutching. Slipping the clutch creates a lot of heat, and it’s not good for the clutch assembly, especially the friction plates, which run quite expensive. The traditional fins surrounding the cylinder block help it stay cool.

These engines are easier to work on as they’re essentially air-cooled. If something goes wrong, you can DIY the hell out of it without risking permanent damage. They also don’t have to trade their cooling fins around the cylinder block for the oil radiator.

KTM engine liquid cooled water jacket
Liquid Cooled Engine Of KTM 390 – Notice The Lack Of Fins On The Cylinder Block

What Is A Liquid-Cooled Engine?

These have a jacket of coolant instead of the cooling fins. It wraps around the entire engine assembly including the gearbox and clutch cover. It takes over the cooling duties as a pump circulates the coolant through a zigzagging pipe hiding behind sharp fins called the radiator. A fan is also there, which jumps in if the speed isn’t enough to chill the coolant.

You won’t (generally) find fins on a liquid-cooled engine as they do it no good. The water jacket is enough to keep the engine within its operating temperature.

KTM Radiator Fins
KTM Radiator Fins

Also Read: How High Compression Can Lead To Knocking

Thanks to better heat management, a liquid-cooled engine can run for a longer duration and at a higher compression (higher compression means more powerful firing in the engine which translates to more heat). Liquid cooling keeps the heat within manageable limits.

That’s until something goes wrong. If you have a bad pump, fan or a leak in the coolant, then you better call roadside assistance. An easy fix in case of low coolant level would be adding water to the mix. The coolant anyways contains a large quantity of distilled water in it.

For more effective heat management, I use Motul coolant in my track motorcycles. As an added benefit you don’t have to figure out the perfect ratio of water: coolant as Motul coolant comes premixed already. You can check it out here

KTM Radiator Assembly With Fan
KTM Radiator Assembly With Fan

Oil Cooled Is Marketing Gimmick

The term ‘oil cooled’ can be considered a marketing gimmick as it doesn’t accurately convey the functionality. A more precise term to define the feature would be ‘oil is cooled‘. Bajaj can be called out in this case as they were the first ones to market Pulsar as “oil cooled”.

Oil Cooled Triumph Street Twin
A Casual Observer Will Think That This Triumph Street Twin Has An Air-Cooled Engine

What About Triumph Bonnevilles?

They’re an exception. The classic series of Triumphs under the Bonneville umbrella not only have fins around the cylinder but they also have a radiator. The purpose behind is to lend them a vintage appearance without sacrificing on the modern technology and features. The trick is to retain its old-school charm while hiding the tech in plain sight. Also Read: What to do if your car engine overheats

How oil cooled and liquid cooled BMW GS Compares (Video)

Image Copyrights: Respective owners

Click to rate this post!
[Total: 1 Average: 5]
Motorcycles: Oil Cooled vs Liquid Cooled
Article Name
Motorcycles: Oil Cooled vs Liquid Cooled
Have been noticing a large number of small capacity bikes are oil cooled. Is it the same as liquid cooling? We compare these two methods of heat management on a motorcycle. Watch video of how liquid cooled BMW GS compares to oil cooled GS.
Publisher Name
Motoring Junction
Publisher Logo